First - I gotta hand it to you babes, you’re digging in! A few of you are dancing pretty close to the answer. For a lot of folks who read that particular book, the character in question was memorable. So it’s not impossible. BUT! If no one gets it this week, I’ll just let that contest ride until someone wins it, since the prize is sorta kinda a good one.
In the meantime, I will announce a winner for the I’m Demanding contest Friday and start a new, regular SHaQ on Monday. The Balgaire Contest will just run secondary to the weekly contests until someone gets it. Or until The Great Scot hits the shelves and is no longer a cool prize. Whichever comes first. (That gives you like, ten months to get the job done.
)
A clarification on that prize - it will be a while before I have advance reading copies of The Great Scot, but you will still get your copy MONTHS in advance of it hitting the shelves. It will just be awhile before it lands on your doorstep.
Okay…now on to some American Idol MAC…
We’re down to five and I’m recapping as I’m watching….
Ryan’s rocking the skinny tie. (Hi Anthony Federov!) Hello, Randy, Paula, and Simon…
So, tonight they each sing two songs. One from the year they were born, one from today’s Billboard charts.
Eliot is up first singing a song from 1978 (he’s a fellow Virginian, yeah!) and has chosen George Benson’s classic On Broadway which I absolutely love.
He’s rockin’ a nice tan jacket and gold tie (still too wide for me!) and acid washed jeans look…and rocking the song pretty well, too. Really bringing the personality. He doesn’t have George’s scat-ability, but he’s totally going for it. Yay, Eliot. I liked it. (And Ace is in the audience, cheering him on. Awwwww. )
Judges? Randy says it started rough, but he pulled it together. Paula gives a thumbs up. Simon says it wasn’t his best, disjointed, and he’s lucky he has another song. I think Simon is off on that one, and we’re usually more in sync. Maybe I’m just excited..I’ll have to relisten later. But I was really entertained.
Next up is Paris talking with Ryan on the Barstool of Make the Audience Love Me. She talks about her childhood and tells him her first song is from 1988 (I’m older than dirt, y’all) and she’s singing Prince’s hit Kiss which really surprises me. It’s not a real singer’s song. And it’s a bit hormonal for Paris to pull off. I’m thinking it’s just me, but between Prince and Tom Jones….I’d rather hear a man do this one. Must be the subject matter.
She looks cute with her curls, dazzly pink rhinestone cross pendant and white vest shirt and black, peg leg capris. Here we go!
She’s going for it, I have to give her that. Vamping it up in the audience, walking the behind-the-judges catwalk, but there’s not a lot of music to back up what is more a spoken than sung song, if you know what I mean. She does fine with what she has to work with, but I’m not sure it’s enough. Okay, the “think I’m gonna dance, uh!” booty shake might get her a few votes. LOL! She should have gone all breathy kitten on that last “Kiss”…but no. So, not sure. I don’t think there was enough to it, but judges?
Randy says she had fun, and that’s cool, dawg. Paula likes her older songs better. Simon says it was screechy and annoying. I wouldn’t go that far. Simon is being the crankypants tonight (even for Simon.) Someone needs to spike his Coke.
Next up is Chris - can’t wait to see what he does!
1979 is the year and he goes with Renegade from Styx which is perfect for him. Dressed in all Johnny Cash black, complete with hip chain, he starts a capella. Background singers come in, then he goes straight hard core…but you know, it’s kind of strangely flat. He’s singing just fine and I’m thinking it’s more the band or something. I don’t know, but it’s not coming together for me, even though he’s singing great. Maybe it’s too much of a monotone shouty song. He pulls it together on the last line. It’s tough because these songs have been chopped down to maybe one minute , maybe 90 seconds tops (so they can all do two songs in an hour) and so what parts they choose to keep (whoever does the arrangement, I don’t know if it’s the singer) is crucial. I think this was mostly hit with a tiny bit of miss. The end was good. We’ll see if the judges agree…
Randy says he’s the Hot One Tonight. Paula says he set the bar. Simon? Says it was a million times better than the first two and a great song choice. I’m definitely with him on that last part. And he performed well - very rock star, all over the stage.
I think I want to go back and listen to all of these again - which is a good sign. But also because they are so short, you don’t have a lot of time to form an opinion. But, so far, no bombs.
Next up is Kat on the Barstool of Contemplation with Ryan… She’s got a slender brown skirt/strapless top ensemb. The year is 1984 and she’s chosen Against The Odds by Phil Collins (or was it Genesis? - they’re making me SHaQ because they’re not telling us the title or artist in some cases.)
I’m pretty sure she just totally blew the opening lyrics. Good cover, but totally went off track, forgot some words. She jumped back in on the chorus. Okay, she’s blowing this whole thing, or they really did a huge rearrangement and I’m just not getting it. Poor Kat!
Judges - Randy was just okay, Paula didn’t think it was strong, and neither did Simon…but no one says anything about botched lyrics. I swear it was a complete mess. Must have been the arrangement. Somewhere Phil weeps. The first bomb of the night for me.
Ryan seems to get that she botched it, so I feel a little redeemed.
Last in the first round is Taylor with a song from 1976. The group is Wild Cherry and he’s going to rock Play That Funky Music White Boy which is totally cracking my behindy up. God, this is going to be entertaining, one way or the other. He comes out in jeans, an untucked paisley, long sleeved shirt and boogies right off….pretty damn well, I might add. This is Taylor UnHinged, y’all. He is totally going for this. Again, it’s not a real singer’s song, but it’s fun. And the crowd is totally into it, because he’s dancing his ass off. Funky white boy, indeed. In the audience, up on stage, and in the end, flat on his back in the middle of the stage. Now THAT was a performance. Not sure about the singing, but it was fun!
Randy - laughing, likens it to drunken karaoke, but agrees he was having fun. Paula loves it as quintessential Taylor, which is it, then incoherently messes with Simon, and Simon? Does not surprise me by hating it. This is not a song Simon would ever get, no matter who sang it! I don’t care. It was fun and we all need more of that. Ryan and Taylor reprise the fall to the ground move at the end and talk to the camera from their backs. Those wacky guys.
Time for Round 2…Ryan gives us a primer on the Billboard Hot 100 lists….and wow, hard to believe the Idol finalists from the past 4 seasons have racked up a collective 90 Number 1 hits. Number 1, y’all. Pretty damn impressive, that. Now each of this seasons five finalists will chose a song from any of the current Billboard charts (whatever genre list they want.)
Eliot is up first with Home by one of my favorites, Michael Buble. Sort of an eclectic choice as a lot of people don’t know him and we all know how America hates stuff they don’t know. And he has that “going first” curse. Hmm…. Eliot, you’re scaring me here.
He starts seated on a barstool…and he’s no Michael. It’s okay, but kind of flat. Maybe a ballad wasn’t a good idea since this isn’t a huge one and it’s more or less unknown. Sigh. Eliot, Eliot, Eliot. Not bad, but definitely forgettable. I think my boy might be in trouble. Unless Kat tanks again. (I know it’s supposed to be Paris booted next, and Kiss didn’t do her any favors, but it was more memorable than this. If she rocks her second song…I dunno, people.)
Judges, Randy really liked it. Paula loved it. Simon EXACTLY repeats my concerns. And so…we’re back in sync. Sob.
Next up is Paris…with a Mary J Blige song, Be Without You (and thank goodness they’re telling us what and who this time!) She’s in some weird cammy satin combo with a red belt. Hmm. the Paris of old is back. She’s got the pipes to do Mary J credit, no doubt. But…maybe it is her turn. I wanted to fast forward almost immediately even though she is doing a really fine job - especially once she gets to the chorus. She does as good as you can do with this, but not sure she’s connecting - you know, in that way Paris never seems to do even when she sings really well.
I think, so far, Chris might be the only safe one. With only five to choose between and to dial in for, anybody, I guess could be in danger if people don’t remember to vote for who they love in addition to who they are trying to save. Everyone needs votes tonight.
So, judges…Randy really liked it. Paula liked it okay. Simon really liked it - nice to hear tonight! Maybe that will earn her a few extra votes. We’ll see. Still don’t think she’ll make it to the end.
Next up is Chris - with I Dare You from Shine Down. Here we go (with the flames of hell screen saver behind him…woooo. Except, not really.) He’s added a black leather suit jacket, which looks pretty good. The song is okay, he does a Chris job with it. No surprises - it’s right up his alley. A bit scratchy on his screamy parts, voice is a little shot, but…still okay. Not my favorite, but I doubt this would send him home.
Randy agrees on the scratchy voice, didn’t really like it. Paula agrees. Simon is concerned his voice is shot - and it seemed more like sincere concern than criticism, which was nice. All in all…they like him, didn’t like the song, hope his voice recovers.
And now Kat with one of my favorites (or used to be until America discovered her, too and played it to death) KT Tunstall and Black Horse and the Cherry Tree. Given that I’ve seen KT sing this and..well…pardon me but it seems a really strange choice for Kat. Have NO idea how she’s going to pull this off. Guess I’m gonna find out!
She’s on the floor with two guys doing the percussion that KT does all by herself AND sings at the same time (you really have to see her perform – it’s great!) Kat is going for it here…but the whole sliding around on the floor and walking on your knees thing? No. Kat never is real comfortable in her own skin, but this is not the solution. Please get up. She teases us for a bit, but no. It’s distracting and not attractive. She’s doing a pretty good rendition of the song and I’d be really enjoying it – but girl needs to GET UP. This could have been a show stopper if she wasn’t all over the damn floor. Are you getting how much I hated that part? Song was really good though.
Randy liked it. Paula liked the choreography, but, well, Paula. Simon says it’s a strange night with people all over the floor, but he really likes the song. I agree there.
Commercials - loved the Cotton commerical and the “Clothes That Get You Fired” store. Hee.
Here we go with the finale of the night and Taylor. He is doing a re-release from The Beatles with Something. Talk about a change up from Funky White Boy.
Very nice Clooney suit and ‘do. He does a nice job with the song, too. A quiet Taylor vibe. I’m liking it a lot more than I thought I would. Might have to vote for this guy. For me, this is the song of the night. Would have never guessed. And a ballad! What’s wrong with me?
Randy dug it, so did Paula. Both seemed as surprised as I was. Such a classic and so overdone, but he did it beautifully. Simon is shocked, too. He really liked it. We’re all pleasantly stunned. Nice closer, Taylor. Really nice.
Tomorrow night isn’t going to be easy! I could see Kat or Paris go. And, much as I hate to say it, Eliot was pretty much invisible tonight. Could be him. I don’t think anyone is going to remember he’s in danger enough to vote for him. I think Chris and Taylor will be fine, though. I think they might be our final 2. Sorry, Eliot! Sob!
What did you guys think?
Tags: Writing by Donna
8 Comments »