We get theme weeks in the semis this season. Kicking it off is 60’s week.
David Hernandez was a good opener, tho the last few notes were a bit rough. I like him. Judges were gentle.
Chikezie started off rough for me, but he pulled it up in the end. Then Simon calls him Jacuzzi by mistake, and it sort of went downhill from there…
David Cook…I liked his rendition of Happy Together….in the beginning. Wish he”d kept that slowed down version. Once he took off it was a bit ahead of itself the rest of the time. But I still like his zen-ness. I’m alone as the judges loved the frantic part.
Jason Yaeger is up next, one of the few over-25’s this time around (last season there was more over than under. Totally opposite this season.) He has a young son, who is a cutie. And he’s a cutie. And it was great seeing him go for it. Beyond that, we know little. But we want to know more! He sings Moon River. Hard to be really distinct with this standard, and while he (mostly) has a lovely voice, I don’t feel we know him any better now than before. Judges were constructive. (I know!)
Rocker Robbie Carrico of little-to-no-airtime is up next…and we discover he actually has a boy band past. Well, it was a boy/girl band, which he was in when he was 16 (now 27, so eleven years back, long time) but, oh yeah, that girl/boy band happened to tour with Britney Spears. Which would have been back during her hey day, not her current haze days. So, some background with this guy, but he wants to rawk, dontcha know. So….well, can he? We’re about to find out. He’s singing Three Dog Night’s One (which I never thought of as a 60’s song…I would have said 70’s. God, I’m old)…and it’s is a song I love. Don’t screw this up, Rawk Boy. So, here he goes, and….he looks disturbingly like my son’s best friend, so that’s kind of weird to be looking at and hearing, then he kind of rushes through the opening and, well, it’s not distinct for me. When it could have been. He’s got a good voice. He just sort of sings merrily along with it, very serviceably, but he really doesn’t get the crowd truly into it and never really goes full tilt rawker, even at the end. But he has promise. I hope. Also interesting that they get back up singers. Judges were more into it than I was, and Simon felt it was done in a current style, whereas, thus far, not so much. On that, I’m agreed. But then, it’s a non-60’s sounding 60’s song. (Cuz, seriously, not 70’s? I would have sworn…. Must have been December 1969….) He’s very twinkly-eyed and cute, so I get Simon questioning his rock-ness, but I buy that’s who he is, or certainly who he wants to be. But let’s see more!
So now we get David Archuleta, he of the previously paralyzed vocal chords and also the previous winner of Star Search. And yeah, he’s short, and cute, but he’s 17. So I don’t think he loves being called Little David Archuleta. Ryan. That said, I do like his infectious smile, and he can sing his heart out, but that past paralysis has left a kind of tightness in the back of his throat, and though it’s freaking amazing that this kid came back and can sing at all, much less as good as he does, it’s a tone thing that just…isn’t my thing. I know, I’m kicking a puppy. But not really. It’s just a musical taste thing. So, then he’s the only one so far to come out and totally dominate the stage straight off. Straight. Off. He’s so comfortable up there and very authentic. I take it all back. Well, not the tight tone thing, that just bugs, I can’t help it, but you can’t help but love this kid. Great song choice. He really works great with the back up singers. He’s has so much passion for what he’s doing. But it’s the absolute joy it gives him on top of that, that shines through. And that counts for a lot. The crowd is really engaged. Finally. Judges rightfully praise him. Really, no contest. And it completely touches him. So, keep the humble thing for as long as you can, David. It looks good on ya!
Next is Danny Noriega, and though he can totally sing, totally, he’s kind of the anti-Archuleta for me. In fact, he has a very strong Sanjaya-like vibe for me. I just don’t buy into his particular brand of cuteness. I know. Clearly I’m ice cream deficient as I watch this. But…the boy can sing. No doubt. Still…Elvis? He channels…well, not macho alpha swagger. And I’ll leave it at that. Word of advice, stick with cute. Or emo. Macho…not so much. It would also help to stay on beat. Judges? Randy and Paula dance around it. Simon clearly has a bigger problem with his precociousness than I do, because he blisters this kid a new one. And while it seems over the top harsh, personally? I think it’s exactly what this kid needs early on. Given the ‘tude, however, I don’t think he’ll actually do anything with it. A shame. Because, love him or hate him, (and though he’s a fare more verbally harsh than I’d ever be, I do generally agree with more often than his compatriots) Simon Sways Voters. Say it with me, Danny. Then embrace it, or learn the hard way. Just sayin.
Luke Menard, another invisible finalist. He looks all hot and mature, but the voice that comes out is Boy Band, Early Timberlake. Very early. So…I’m not sure. But he does look mighty fine. (Pass the ice cream.) And I loved the way his wife just naturally patted him on the ass as they were hugging and jumping up and down when he got his golden ticket. I’d pat him, too. (Really. Pass the scooper.) So he sings Everybody’s Talking. Very soft singer, very safe. Cute, but not charismatic. I fast forwarded. Sorry! I hope he gets a chance to show us more. Maybe if he sang shirtless… Judges…agreed with me across the board. Finally! And Simon nailed it. It’s why I couldn’t sit through it.
Now get Ellen Degener–wait, no, that’s Colton Berry. He’s from my neck of the country, so it will be interesting to see what he does. He takes on Elvis, too, but chooses Suspicious. You immediately understand the thing about his theatricality, which, considering his theater background is kind of duh. But it makes him come across more “performancey” than authentically. Like he’s playing at being a pop singer instead of just being one. He does have charisma though, and a great voice, not to mention he is very comfortable up there. It would be interesting to see where he goes…I’d keep him in.
17 yr old Garrett Haley. Okay, seriously, who is this kid? Leif Garrett 2K8? (I know, half of you are like, who’s Leif Garrett? Me? Old. As. Dirt.) But have we ever even seen this guy? Hopefully he’ll bring it, because so far tonight, very serviceable, very good technical singers, but nothing has really grabbed me. (I’m still waiting on Dread Lock Guy. Another of the Invisible Ones. And don’t forget Aussie Man.) Oh my god. Ryan totally just called the Leif Garrett thing. I feel so much….younger now. And Frampton! Yeah, definitely that, too. So…here we go. A very sweetly sung ballad. Actually, very nice if you like that kind of thing. I imagine teenyboppers everywhere are swooning. Me? Not so much. Next? But, he’s listening to the criticism and taking it to heart. Danny.
So, FINALLY, we get to hear the Dreadlock Guy, Jason Castro, who has been beyond invisible. He’s the first one to take advantage of the play-along-instrument clause this year. Boy, I hope that pans out for you. We’d like to know you for more than five seconds. Okay, I totally like him straight off, and I think it’s a corny song and I don’t even care. Love his eyes, great smile, the dreads are interesting. He’s shy and adorable and he can sing. Shoot me. The audience was into it, too. So there! Charisma squared. The ending lost me a little, and yet? My favorite so far this night! I don’t even know exactly why. And don’t care! Then Simon goes and totally agrees with me? And, this is exactly what I was just saying. Ha. Way to becoming instantly visible, man!
Pass the damn ice cream already! We still have Aussie Man to go!
He closes the show (big shock!) and? Just as great as we expected. Better maybe. That? Is a star. 29, Michael John, Aussie, Gorgeous, Tall. Comes straight out and tackles Jim Morrison (because, duh.) Loved it. Loved the scarf. Finally a MANLY voice. Sigh. Dayum. I’m a happy girl. That said, I hope he comes in 4th and goes the non-Idol, Daughtry route. Just sayin.
So, after Semi Final Round 1 - the ones to beat, David, Jason, and Michael.
Which two should go home after tonight? Jason Yaeger, Luke Menard, and….well, I’d love to see Danny go, but that’s just the mean mom in me.
Girls tomorrow night. Will be interesting to see the contrast.
Aaand, dish! Who was your fave, who was not so much? Who can lick ice cream off your spoon anytime? Just asking…..
Tags: Writing by Donna
No Comments »