Based on the Blog Babe Poll, I think we have a pretty good idea which gender it’s going to be, that is if America feels as we do. (And, well, they certainly should, since we’re right.
)
But, now that we’ve seen their performances this week, does everyone still feel the same?
Here are my thoughts as I watched the show…
Nice new stage, very Idol-ish. But I’m not sure if I like the band in their sky suite. I kind of like a band to be down with the singer, but we’ll see…
Tonight we get the much vaunted Lennon-McCartney songbook, which definitely gives them a wide set of options, if they, indeed, have the whole book to choose from. We also discover that it’s not just the songs they sang themselves, but also includes songs they wrote for others.
First up is Syesha and she opts for Got To Get You Into My Life, which is a song I always enjoy listening to, but I hope it’s not too Standard McCartney Pop Song to stand out. Well, the band sounds good! And she tries to command the stage - she’s not intimidated, that much is clear. But the song, the singing, is just okay for me. (God, I sound like Randy. I’m just keeping it real.) The last bit of change up was the best part for me, but it was too little too late. Judges? Randy said he wasn’t sure about going with the Earth, Wind & Fire version, but it got better as she went on. Paula mostly agrees. Simon completely screws with my head by really liking it much more than the Keepin It Real Duo, which clearly also throws Syesha off, too. I’m usually in sync with the Evil Brit, though I’d never be as harsh to the person’s face as he is, so I’m….I don’t know. I guess we’ll see how the rest of the night goes. It wasn’t that great, Simon. Rilly. It wasn’t nerves, she had no problems with the stage.
Next up is Chickezie…I thought his video was kind of endearing. He’s singing an early song, She’s A Woman, and says he’s adding the funk. We’ll see. He starts on the stairs with a few musicians and a bluegrass feel and, wow, I LOVE this version straight off, then he stands up and totally cuts loose and I am completely bowled. Damn, dude, who knew he had that in him? This is exactly what he had to do to arrive. Damn, now that’s a Top 12, incredibly righteous performance right there. Beat that, people! I double dare ya. That makes me want to vote. And the crowd goes freaking wild. I’ll listen to what the judges have to say just as soon as I listen to that bad boy one more time. Wow. Judges? They lose their collective minds, too. That was a lot of fun.
Poor Ramiele - who has failed to move me even once, other than when she’s sobbing during the vote off sing out. I would NOT want to follow that performance, so she’s got double the duty to pull off now, as far as I’m concerned. She’s singing In My Life which she dedicates to her close friends who have left the show already. Read: Danny. Here we go…and, for me, it’s the same old Ramiele. Something about the way she moves her mouth when she sings has always distracted me, and not in a good way. Like she just got botoxed and isn’t used to her lips being puffier. Mostly, I just feel as if she’s just singing this song as it was written, in a very sweet, serviceable way. What I don’t feel, at any time, is that she’s really emotionally connected to what the song is about. This is a very moving song, and…I’m not all that moved here. But, could be me. Judges? Randy says it was boring. (Agreed.) Paula compliments her beauty, which is a nice way of saying, that’s all I have nice to say. She says it was too safe. (Agreed.) Simon, in his brutal simplicity, says he was bored to tears with a song that did absolutely nothing for her. Harsh, yes. But…true. Aaaaaand, the planets realign. And, wow, what really ticked me? She was all “It’s okay” when they were feeling a bit bad for being tough on her, but then when Randy said he wasn’t sure she’d done enough to stay next week, she gets this surprised look. Like, sweetheart, have you NOT been reading the news? The girls days are already numbered this season -and you think you can just float through a week? Even Chikezie knew you had to seriously bring it - you’re playing with the big boys now, literally. No more girl-on-girl action, and even then, I think you might be in trouble. So, just…Wow. Now I’m not only not impressed, but now I’m not liking her a lot either. Stop with the Cute Pout and start singing better. Sheesh. (And Paula, shut up. They all have beautiful voices at this point.)
Next? Yay, it’s Jason’s turn! Wow, he has such a wiiiiiiide range to choose from that would showcase him stunningly. Lennon’s songs were made for a singer like him. (Okay, what is Ryan on? He’s wound tight tonight. Or just tight.) But, back to Our Jason… Like Ramiele, he mentions his first Lennon/McCartney song was Yesterday, and, like Ramiele, he chooses something different. I was relieved with Ramiele because I thought she’d be boring (turns out, it didn’t matter, she was boring anyway) but Jason I thought could pull it off. But he goes with If I Fell, which I’m much happier about, as it’s a happier tune, and Yesterday is just soo played out. (Wonder if anyone actually tries to pull it off. Maybe Archuleta could…) Here we go…with the guitar (squee!) He gives it the Castro Catchy-Breathy treatment, and while it’s not Chikezie-crazy-making, I really like it. But, I’m SO biased. Admittedly so. He’s my very favorite cute woodland creature… Judges? Randy says it was alright, but he wasn’t 100 percent behind some of the change ups. Paula…wow, do I have to recap her allll season? She’s Paula. Then Simon Says it was all a little bit Student In A Bedroom At Midnight. (Where does he come up with ths stuff? Was he sipping Paula’s coke?) I do get what he’s saying, and he does qualify it by saying he likes the guy, but not that song. Still, it’s My Woodland Creature, so I ignore and just gaze upon the natural beauty whilst I can.
There is Ryan-Simon banter that hasn’t worked for me once as yet this season, so I ignore that too.
Our Irish Lass is up next…Carly Smithson. She sings Come Together in an acoustic arrangement at the pub she works at, so she decides to go with that here as well. I sort of thought that would be Amanda’s choice, so this is kind of interesting… And, you know…I don’t know how I feel about this. Partly because she’s got this weird blue silk thing on that’s very distracting, and partly because there is an Amanda Overmeyer in this competition, and I can’t help but hear her sing this in my head as Carly is singing it, which makes Carly come off kind of like a poseur. As Simon would say, Sorry! The crowd clearly completely disagrees with me as they give her the next craziest response after Chickezie. Judges? Randy declares it as stellar. Paula says she’s already a star, blah blah blah. Simon Says (okay, can I say the chest hair exposure is really sort of distracting, only I’m not sure it’s in an entirely bad way, which is really confusing me….) Simon thinks this was her first great song choice. Maybe it was just the Amanda thing, I don’t know. (And that blue dress is hideous.) But then he goes on to say that this reminds him of season one, same week…..Kelly Clarkson. So…wow. The planets go awry once again.
We hear that David Cook is going to sing Eleanor Rigby, and we have an entire commercial break to ponder that bit. Hmm….commercial over and I’m still not sure how I feel. Guess I’ll know in a second when he starts singing… He does seem to get the importance of making sure every aspect is well thought out…so, good on him for that much. After last week, I really hope he pulls this off. I’m liking the guy. Still don’t want to watch him, but i do like how he sounds. (Then there is this really distracting bit with Ryan whispering at Simon right before he starts singing, which, really? Not cool.) And…here we go. FINALLY. He does an okay job. Again, listen without watching and it’s better. Though I kinda dig the jacket. He rocks the ending totally, in the way that Carly totally didn’t for me. So who knows. He had a great time, and is clearly pumped, which says a lot. I’ll be interested to see what the judges think…. Judges? Randy says he can rock out and loved it. Paula says he’s a great front man. Simon Says he thought it was brilliant. In fact, he says, if this season remains a talent competition, rather than a popularity contest (which, arguably, so far, it has) he thinks Our David Cook could win the whole shebang. After Hello, and an also arguably good turn out this week with such a diehard classic…he might be on to something there. And not something found in Paula’s cup.
Now, we get to Brooke Stepford White…. She chooses the last single recorded by the Beatles, Let It Be. I’m SO not excited about that. I hope she proves me wrong. And, seated at a grand piano, she does an okay job. Her voice was a little rough and didn’t quite have the range to really belt it out. It’s still too much a classic for me to feel something hearing anyone else sing it, and the urge to hit the fast forward button was strong, like it was with Ramiele tonight. Sorry! Judges - Randy says she has conviction and that’s what sold it for him. Paula says she found her niche. Simon Says he thought it was one of the best of the night. Really? What is wrong with me? Man, I am so out of sync. Because, no, it really wasn’t. Not for me. Not by a long shot. But her sincerity in describing the moment afterward did win me over a wee bit.
David Hernandez next. He’s pretty smooth in his interview, and if you didn’t know about the whole stripper lap dance thing, you might really like this dude and be all awwww, cute after school pizza bistro job… Except we do know what you did last summer. David. But then he chooses I Saw Her Standing There. One of FAVE tunes. And I hope he rocks this out. Otherwise, he totally owes me a lapdance. Just sayin. Win win for me. So, he starts on the catwalk behind the judges seat and it’s very kind of….stripperish, the opening of this performance. It is, too! It’s got a little Buddy Holly sound to it, as he goes on, that’s kind of…well, whack. I don’t know. It’s not entirely Luke’s A Go Go performance lite, but….not the top of the night. In fact, bottom of the guys so far. (Only Ramiele scores lower, with Syesha close after him.) I know, I’m so crabby! I will say that this whole Top 12 is head and shoulders above previous seasons, which affords me the chance to slam really good singers. But it also affords me the chance to discern between really great singers, and really great singers who also have superstar potential. I’m not thinking he’s got the latter going for him. But then, there is that lap dance thing…… The judges, for once, agree with me, but all I’m thinking is why, why didn’t Chikezie get a later spot because we could a performance of that caliber right about now.
Amanda Overmeyer’s turn and in five seconds she’s already smiled more than she has the entire time she’s been caught smiling the entire season. A little “how to win fans and influence voters” coaching, anyone? Bueller? She picks You Can’t Do That. She chose it after hearing it for the first time this week, so I’m guessing….not a big Beatles fan, since she has no memories to share with us about loving them in the past. Given she doesn’t have the history of it, it will be interesting to see what she does with it. Wow. Damn good job. Chikezie good. Loved it. The first time I’ve truly loved her this entire season. What she just did is what, for me, Carly couldn’t do earlier. So…sue me. She sang without really going all gravelly. Still all throaty, but really singing it this time. Loved. It. Only the second time tonight I did the playback. Dang. She also had a blast up there. Judges - Randy loved it. Paula is bubbling over. Of course, she’s had a lot of coke by now. Simon Says he didn’t think it was as good as last week and it was too slurry for him. He has no clue about southern bar band rock, which is exactly what she did to that song. And it was freaking brilliant. But, I get what he’s saying. He’s just wrong.
Michael Johnsnext - yay! He’s singing Across The Universe, which is personal for him. So, I hope he pulls this off. He sings this more purely than he has the past few weeks…I must admit I listened to him and found myself wondering how Jason would have handled this song, and even David Cook, which, not a good sign. But I did like this version okay. Judges? Randy says it was a little sleepy, but aiiright. Of course Paula disagrees, because he’s a cutie and she loves all cuties. Simon Says he agrees with Randy and thinks he should have done something like Carly did, to stand out more, but he’s still a fan. Just wants that breakout performance. And….here I agree with him.
Kristy Lee is up. She’s singing 8 Days A Week and going country with it. Simon doesn’t always get country, so I don’t know how well her dream that he appreciates this will go, but here we go. Okay, is it me, or is the beat all speeded up and not matching her all speeded up, even a little bit? I like the country twang, but what was that arrangement on speed for? Wow. A shame. Could have been a solid performance for her. Judges - agreed.
David Archuleta is last up! (There’s a surprise.) He chose We Can Work It Out because he was familliar with the Stevie version, but is nervous as he’s never connected with the Beatles. Which is surprising, given I’d think they’d be right up his save-humanity-save-the-starving-children alley. Oh well….this could be interesting. Wow, I’m stunned - but the consummate performer since he was like, what, 4? He Forgot. The. Lyrics. Wow, he must have really been stressing over this, which is crazy given he can sing pretty much anything and be pretty spectacular just because. So…instead he’s kind of totally tanking this. Who knew? It’s kind of oddly endearing. But dangerous! Judges - Randy hates on it. Paula calls him on the lyric forgetting. Simon informs him it’s only fair to judge him as he does everyone else and that it was a mess. (See, he’s being kind. I’d have said stone cold mess. Who knew I could be harsher than Simon when we both think it sucks?) I know he likes the kid, so he probably hates the hatin’, but he’s right. David totally tanked that.
So, in watching the recaps, here’s how I rank it:
Chikezie, just because it was such an unexpected turn around.
David Cook
Amanda Overmeyer (I know, such a shock for me to like her this much)
Jason Castro
Carly Smithson (with a different outfit, she might have moved up one.)
Brooke White
Michael Johns
Syesha Mercado
Ramiele Malubay
David Hernandez
Kristy Lee
And, shocking, to me, David A in last place.
So, you have until tonight at 9EST to get your votes in for this week’s SHaQ Attack contest. (See Monday’s post for details.)
Winner announced tomorrow!
Now, I promised some news on how to win more cool stuff! Fellow Brava author, Dianne Castell has a new release out this month, Hot & Bothered, and so they’re having a big ol’ blog party to celebrate. And part of that celebration is giving away a lot of free books by all your fave Brava authors. So, starting tomorrow and going through Friday, I will have a link here that will send you right to the party!
So…about Idol. You know, this is shaping up to be quite the interesting season. I’m hooked. Can’t wait to see what they all do next week. Who did you love? Who made you cringe? Who made you cry? Who wants to bet Ramiele cries? Who should go home? Who should stay, even if they tanked? It’s such a diverse group, I can see some wildly varying feelings out there. Share!
Aaaaaaand, dish!
Tags: Writing by Donna
3 Comments »