Okay, it’s like they got together on So You Think You Can Dance, and went, ooooh, let’s pair everyone with everyone who is left, maybe even bring back cool choreographer Wade Robson, and then, um……yeah, pick every single dance style of Donna hates and make them do that. Thanks, show.
Seriously. Lyrical, Broadway, Jive, Fox Trot and, wait for it, Russian dancing. Which I didn’t know I didn’t like so much until I had to watch it. Yes, yes, I totally get that it was physically insane. It was also kind of like Cold War Comedy from yester-milennium.
Yes, we did get Twitch and Courtney with NappyTabs hip hop, which - who dressed Courtney tonight and why in the hell do they hate her so much? Yikes on her costumes. Which were really….costumey. And the hip hop was okay, kind of intersting in places, cute. But who knew that was the highlight? I should have just watched that over and over.
It’s not that the remaining performances were bad, they were all actually quite brilliant in their own way. But mostly what I took from them was they were exhausting. Like the choreographers all got together and said, “I can make them work harder than you! Let’s run them into the ground! Good times!” So my pleasure quotient was decidely diminished because I was exhausted just watching them and it started to feel very “trained monkey” to me after a while. As I said, don’t get me wrong - some brilliant stuff. But, my god, would it have killed the choreo’s to let them freaking breathe for a moment? Think about what Josh and Twitch had to do, especially Josh, going from that Russian routine, straight to that Jive on Crack number, and then hardly a breath before Mia’s insane Braveheart Meets Mama Mia finale.
There was mention in the press a few days ago that two dancers were taken to the hospital at one point during the week for collapsing. No mention was ever made about which ones collapsed, though word is it was Twitch and Joshua - does that shock anyone? - and Nigel went out of his way tonight to talk about how they don’t care if they’re half dead, or even all dead, the audience wants their show, dammit. So, dance monkeys dance! Seriously, it was just a little much. And less entertaining for it. I wanted to yell, “Slow the hell down already!” I wanted to stand by the stage much the same way they do during marathons with cups of water for the runners.
So…I wasn’t happy with the finale, despite the insanely high level of performances they all gave. It was truly amazing any of them were still standing by the end. The judges mostly gushed, but eventually handed out the criticisms also. I know they have a tour to prepare for now, which might end up being more work than the show prep, but at least they’ll just be in front of an audience, and not the world, as they tour. And it will be the same performances week to week, no steep learning curve once the show hits the road. I think they had to be more riduculously relieved than sad in any way that they were done competing when they walked off the floor for the final time last night. I found myself wondering if any of them, as they walked off, was thinking, “Oh thank god, no new routines to learn this week, no pulling freaking Samoan Disco out of the hat!” I know I was happy, and relieved, for them.
So, on to more important things…like who should win? None of the routines this week were going to sway me one way or the other. None moved me to that extent, or to any real extent, anyway. I found myself far more armchair observer than involved viewer for these routines. The only edge of my seat action was worrying they might literally pass out on the floor. So I asked myself who I found myself watching most. Joshua. Maybe it was the Energizer Bunny-ness they all expected of him this week. His jobs in those performances might not have been delivered smoothly or precisely, but damn if he didn’t truck through each one, heaving various girls, even Twitch around, when called upon to do so. Over, and over. And over. And then over again. Just his stamina alone had my respect. Katee pulled me in, too. Courtney was almost manic tonight, and for whatever reason Twitch was entertaining, but not riveting.
So….while Joshua certainly is far and away from being the best dancer on the show, also addressed by Nigel, for entertainment value, charisma, dedication, work ethic, charm, and just plain likeability…I’m going with Josh. A Katee win would be very fine with me. Twitch would get a nod and a golf clap. And, I admit, I’d be disappointed if Courtney won. Not because she hasn’t shown the same chops as Josh and worked every bit as hard, she just doesn’t call to me on those other intangible levels.
What say you, Ameriker? (And did we love Cat’s interviews? There had better be an Emmy nod for her next year. Let her duke it out with Tom Bergeron. I’d be totally game for that.)
And no, I haven’t forgotten about Project Runway and Our Tim. I kinda wish I could as this season has been startlingly unfulfilling as yet. I’ll recap tomorrow after viewing…providing I love the winner for SYTYCD. Otherwise I might be too verklempt. Cross fingers this episode is More Fun For Fashion than the previous ones thus far. Well. It would kind of have to be now, wouldn’t it?
Tag. You’re all it. DISH!!
Tags: Writing by Donna
2 Comments »