Idol n’ Usher…and Bickering With the Stars!
It’s R&B week on American Idol and Usher is taking his mentor role seriously tonight and it’s all a little bit…too…for me. But at least he’s not just phoning it in.
Siobahn is up first, singing Through the Fire. Not sure I agree w/ Usher about her toning down her quirk. I mean, did Lauper? Did Gaga? I think not. But she tones it down all over the place and goes soft with the lead in…and then sharp. A lotta sharp. Yikes. She gets to her big notes, but to my ears it’s more off than on. Big voice, no doubt, but not really controlling it tonight. Not a good start to the night for me. And the overly calm face was kinda spooky, until you realize it’s because she’s trying really hard not to cry. Then you just feel sorry for her. Hopefully having an off night will be motivational and not crushing. Something she needs to learn at some point, anyway.
And, wow, did we need the backstage part? I mean, it’s good to know they’re there for each other, but enough piling on already. What is it with my shows this week? I already suffered through B/DWTS. (See below.) Drama, tension, fighting, nastiness, and a lot of awkward does not a fun entertainment night make. If I wanted that, I’d watch….all the stuff I don’t watch. Because of that. Come on, shows!
Well thank goodness Casey is up next! Woot, woot, and pass the umbrella drinks early in the evening! Looks like we might need ‘em! Singing Hold On, I’m Comin’. Double woot woot! And he’s clearly, so very clearly, in his element. He’s always been confident, but tonight he was On It. Liked the brass, but the backup singers actually brought the energy down. Wish they’d left it just for him to carry, but it was a very good performance. More comfort soul and good guitar licks. Mmm hmm. Workin for me.
Big Mike…ahhhh. The night keeps getting better. And I agree he can play and sing and make you feel…but I’ll also admit I’m ready for him to pump up the energy and do something other than a ballad. Even Teddy P brought it every once in awhile. That said, it was a beautiful piece. And he has a magnetic presence even simply on a stool with a guitar. Really well done. (And good on ya for consoling Siobahn earlier.) Consistent Top 3 for me.
Didi is up next, and….we’ll see. What Becomes of the Broken-hearted is her choice. I was thinking it would be nice behind a piano. She looked lovely. And sang in all of her Didi-ness kind of way, but it’s not my favorite thing. Then the end was rushed and weird and over the top. What was that? And I get why Ryan wanted her to tell us she sang the song to the guy who dumped her and was the reason why she tried out for the show in the first place, because we’d be sympathetic to that and vote for her after the drubbing she just took…I do get that, he wasn’t trying to be cruel. But yikes, more with the awkward. And given she’d just gotten drubbed, I’m sure it wasn’t the “See? I can TOO do this!” moment she wanted to shove in the guy’s face. Or…maybe that’s just me.
It’s Timmy TIme. Yep, that’s who I think about when I think R&B. Freckle-faced kid. Soul man. He’s singing Anita Baker’s Sweet Love. Usher called him out on the believability factor. His youth is showing. And that didn’t change for me while he sang. Just kind of surface-y song for me. I’m sure the teens and tweens will love it, but given he’s been in the bottom three before, I fear he could be booked on a return trip. Randy nailed it - it had no swag.
Andrew is up. I was hoping the talk with Usher might help him focus and give him the one on one info he really needed to be confident as he moved forward. And it did. Because this? Was my favorite Andrew performance BY FAR. Welcome back, dude. That was awesome. I’m finally glad we kept you around. Whew!
Katie. And Usher. Doing R&B. About like Tim Time. Doing Aretha’s Chain of Fools. I’m not really digging this, but I don’t know what she’d have done regardless. I’m sorry. Good voice, but not buying this song from her. Kinda pervy. And the whole look was weirdness.
Lee is up next and I’m thinking he should do okay this week. Singing Treat Her Like a Lady, which should fit his vocal range just fine. Usher was digging it and he hasn’t that much with the rest. I thought he did a really good job with this. Right in his wheelhouse. Very good job. His confidence visibly improved as he went along, which was fun to see. I think that qualifies as a moment.
Finally….Crystal! Midnight Train to Georgia…on the piano this time around. And her chops? They are just so strong and natural it wouldn’t matter what she played, where she stood, or what she sang. She’s just Got It. Great to see her personality, too. Loved it. My favorite of the night. And I loved that she sang it to her husband. Awww. Smooches.
Aaron closes the show and I have to admit I’m not so excited about this, but…he’s cute. He’s singing Ain’t No Sunshine. I hope he has a moment, but I’ve already had mine. So…he’s adorable. And not going anywhere. Nice close.
All in all, a really good night. Huge improvement over last week, but…yeah. My bottom three? Didi, Tim, and Siobahn this week. Assume Didi is done done. Still loving Mike, Crystal, Casey, and Lee, too, this week. Andrew totally brought it, and Aaron is solid. Meh on Katie, think she’s next in the bottom for me. What say you, Blog Babes?
And now…Bickering With the Stars. I was so put off by the performance show, with the tension, bitchy judges, overly stressed out dancers (thanks to waaaaay too much pressure and criticism from the judges affecting both pro and celeb, and it’s week TWO) I was too bitchy myself when it was all over to want to keep the poison going any further. So…wow. Cut it out judging panel. Lighten up. This is supposed to be a fun family show. That? Not even close. Tom can only do so much with the clever quips.
That said, I loved Niecy, like the vibe between Erin and Maks, think Nicole is a ringer, but one who works so damn hard she has my respect anyway. Evan brought personality, Buzz brought charm, Jake and Shannen worked hard, Bobblehead Pam is in touch with herself, pretty much at all times, literally, Aiden needs to be nice to Edyta, Chad needs someone to cut him a huge freaking break, and Kate really, really needs to get very, very far away from my television screen. Now. Free Tony!
So, who is in the Bottom Two? Pam & Damian. Not Buzz. And not Kate. Cats and dogs, living together. Apocalypse on the horizon. I blame it all on the celeb-aquarium. Then, Yay, Pro Dance! Fun to see Ashley really get the chance to go full out with her return to the show. Fun times. Aaaaand, then that was over. And we’re on to the Haitian dance, which…cue the waterworks. That was so tough and so moving…. Wow. Even the Beach Boys couldn’t bring the sunny back. Aaaand, on from there to depression and red lights and people going home who really don’t deserve to. Good times! Shannen and Mark are in the bottom two and Tony is already planning to get completely schnockered after the show is over. Wow. Life, it is unfair. Shannen goes home, Mark is apparently injured anyway, and everyone is sad, and it’s just too painful to look at her disappointed dad..and why, show, why did you lose all your bright and shineyness this week? Please bring back the fun next week. Look it up if you have to. But…do it.
And, what you can do? Is enter this week’s contest. See Monday’s blog post for all the details! Then? You can join me at the shallow end of the pool, umbrella drinks for everyone! And DISH! Who would you have sent home on DWTS? (I don’t think I need to spell my choice out any further.) Who are you rooting for? I’m not really sure on that show as yet. Mostly rooting for the judges to gain some perspective and for everyone to chillax a little. Over on Idol…whose record would you buy? Who should go home tonight? For me, Crystal and Mike for the win, Casey right there with em. Didi or Tim going home makes the most sense.































