On DWTS, Maks & Erin are safe straight up which makes me happy, then Cheryl & Chad get the encore, which was well deserved and rocked it a second time, also making me happy. Melissa Etheridge sings and there is a very manic dance by our pros, who I love, but that was a bit out of control there…so, not as happy, mostly just dizzy. Chad & Cheryl are safe, happiness resumes. Then we get flamenco on crack and eye candy on guitar, all of which is happiness, but back to the results! Which means I skimmed the science thing — I still had singing to watch/blog — but sweet, nonetheless. Watching Dmitry, I mean. Pass the umbrella drinks and join me in the shallow end of the pool!
Melissa comes back with Biggest Hit and the dancing wasn’t frenzied this time. Melissa rocked out in leather while Edyta & Alec showed us why they are a happily married dancing couple. And why we like it. Then Nicole & Derek are safe. Pam & Damien are also in.Jake & Chelsie are in the bottom two. Evan & Anna are safe. Louis & Niecy are the other bottom two couple. It’s not surprising that these couples are in the bottom…and my guess is Jake is out. Am I right? Yep! So, not a shock to anyone. However, given the scores being all over the place, hard to call who will go home next. I’d say Pam, but she didn’t hit the bottom this week…so it’s anyone’s game I think! What do you think?
I think it’s time to see the final six singers on Idol get their Shania on, that’s what I think! I think she was quite the adorable mentor much as she was a guest judge on the road. She wrote and performed these songs, so she gives them great insight which I think/hope would carry over to other performances as well. I’m hoping for a good night at least, anyway!
First up: Lee who will be singing Still The One and, wow, it just didn’t work for me. I like how he tried to change it up, but it came off a bit sharp and flat in delivery. It got better, and would sound good in a studio with refining, but I was itching to fast forward tonight. Sorry. Judges were into it, though. He’ll stay.
Big Mikeaka “Bounty” (you know, the bigger picker upper) is singing It Only Hurts When I’m Breathing…and it’s right for him from her catalogue and I think he did a good job with it. It didn’t give him huge big moments, so not sure if voters will come through for him. It definitely suited him. Judges agree. Except Simon and that hurts, because he wasn’t entirely clear on his point and you could see how disappointed Mike was after the good that came before it. I’m glad they gave Shania a say. Will he stay? I hope so.
A more self reflective Casey is up next. He’s singing Don’t and I think it’s the right week for him to bring the emotional songwriter song. With rhythm guitar he sits and actually sings…and who knew? He can! Yowza, but the love just grows. Judges unanimously agree. And I hope that saves him, because I would like more of that every week, please!
Crystal is singing No One Needs to Know. She’s got back up band on stage and this one is more twangy than the others tonight. She doesn’t look spectacular in her garb, it’s a bit awkward on her figure, but the peppy tune is a nice change after the ballads and the audience latches on to that. The whole thing was quite enjoyable if not a showstopper. Judges all say it wasn’t their fave. Oh sigh. Didn’t you just get done telling her it’s been too samey samey and ya gotta have range? Maybe they’re being harsh in an effort to keep her from the Top 6 Backlash that took J Hud out in season past. If so, then right on. I hope her backtalk doesn’t hurt her.
Aaron is singing You Got A Way and the ballad will work with his voice. It depends on whether he has the conviction to sing it. And he does a really good job, but I think it’s just his age limiting him on this kind of thing. For me, he’s gone as far as he can this season and now needs to step out and just grow up as he continues to work on his music. Fans will most likely disagree. Not saying he’s a bad singer, because he’s got madd talent…just has more growin’ to do for me to get on board. Judges liked it, and thought he nailed it…so what do I know. I don’t want to own songs by him, so that makes it pretty simple for me.
Siobhan closes with Any Man of Mine…and I’m really over her, but will go along for the ride. Just know, I’m not objective here. I don’t want to see or hear her sing anymore. Am I the only one who thought that was flat off key the whole time? And even if we could handle her finally just singing, then…Oh dear. And she screamed anyway. Heh, childbirth scream. Been there, done that. Thankfully not live on stage in front of millions. Siobhan. So, my feelings they do not change. Yeesh.
So…Lee, Mike, Casey, Crystal still make me want to tune in. Aaron and Siobhan, not so much, though I do get Aaron’s appeal. So we all know who I’d like to see go home, but after that performance show, it’s anybody’s guess. At least Shania can go home feeling good about how it all went down.
What say you, Blog Babes! Did the right dancer go home? (For me? Yes.) And who leaves Idol tonight? Well, my favorite of the night was Casey. Crystal was enjoyable. Didn’t dig Lee but think he stays. Enjoyed Mike, but am worried. The other two I can’t ever see myself downloading one of their songs. And? Your turn! DISH!!
Tags: Writing by Donna
5 Comments »